Friday, May 10, 2013
Does Nepali bureaucracy not want elections?
On March 25, 2013 Republica's opinion columnist CK Lal wrote an opinion piece titled "The system triumphs (click for direct link to the piece)" in which he accused the Nepali bureaucracy of not wanting elections. I disagreed with Mr Lal's views, and wrote the following opinion piece published in Republica on May 2, 2013. The direct link is here.
Critics of the newly formed interim council were quick to attack the council for being slow and not striving harder to hold elections in June. The current state of discussions suggests that it will most likely happen in November. In addition, some opinion makers were quick to blame state bureaucrats of being happy with current status quo, and accused them of trying to postpone elections for as long as they can. The implicit suggestion was that local bureaucrats tend to benefit significantly in absence of elected officials. The dread created amongst political activists in Tarai-Madhesh has been cited as an example of how this bureaucratic status quo results in despondency in the system. However, not many have actually bothered to ask the bureaucrats how they feel.
The fact that a status quo situation with no elections stands to benefit a handful of corrupt bureaucrats does not mean the entire bureaucracy is hell-bent on ensuring the postponement of elections. In the past few months, I have had opportunities to observe local and national level bureaucrats speak their opinions on popular public and political perception of Nepali bureaucracy. Contrary to popular belief, the bureaucrats stressed that they want elections just as badly as everyone else. They want local elections to be held before national elections. And many of us thought that they were happy with their current hold on power—handling local level duties of 22 different ministries and 58 different elected officials.
The perception of local bureaucracy being mired in corruption stems from a number of instances of corruption that have occurred and been reported. However, local bureaucrats suggest that transparency and accountability in municipal or VDC level governments is much higher when compared to other line agencies of Nepali government. Therefore, when local bureaucracy honestly reports and disseminates its transparency and accountability findings, Nepali media is quick to pounce on the few ‘negative’ instances in the overall transparent and accountable governance scenario. In other words, much of the perception about corruption in local bureaucracy is a creation of the media, according to local bureaucrats.
Although Nepali bureaucracy, especially VDCs and municipalities, get bad press for occasional instances of corruption, their role in keeping the country functioning during the absence of stable political government has to be lauded. Local elections have not happened in over 14 years, and elected representatives in local bodies have been absent for over 10 years now. In this entire duration, the fact that Nepali state has been functioning, and Nepal has not become a failed state, is a miracle with much credit going to our well oiled bureaucracy.
While accusing the local bureaucracy of mismanagement in decision-making, we have to take into account three kinds of pressures that local bureaucrats have to bear. First, decision-making in local level has to be done in a manner that appeases all sections of local society. Therefore, whether a VDC secretary or municipal executive officer likes it or not, he/she has to seek suggestions from local political actors while making decisions on complex problems. Any complex decision has to be taken with a political buy-in from all local political actors from all parties to ensure that they help in containing any possible public outburst against such decisions.
Second, although all party mechanism (APM) has been officially disbanded by the Nepali government, it still operates as the de-facto decision-making body in the local level. Earlier, when the APMs were created, they only had members from seven different political parties. Therefore, it was easier to come to a consensus in decision-making. However, the de-facto APMs of today consist of dozens of political parties—large and small—which has made decision-making very difficult in local government. Since each party wants a share of the pie, decision-making at local level has been obstructed incessantly in recent times, and productivity of local bureaucrats has fallen due to this obstruction.
Third, when the de-facto APM comes to a consensus and takes a decision, it is the local bureaucrat who has to take ‘ownership’ of that decision and abide by it, because the APM does not ‘technically’ exist in the eye of the law or national government. When questions are raised by activists and media about how budgets are allocated and how projects are undertaken, VDC secretaries and municipal executive officers are thrown under the bus by these de-facto APMs who do not come to the bureaucrats’ assistance in defending those allocations and undertakings.
It is very easy to accuse the entire bureaucracy of being corrupt and opposed to elections. However, the ground realities and interactions with local and national level bureaucrats provide a different understanding. Contrary to popular belief, local bureaucrats recognize that politics of opposition is necessary to make local decision-making process more transparent and accountable. They also realize that bureaucracy is an apolitical mechanism, and that is how it should be. Therefore, they demand local elections as much as the public. It’s just that nobody has been listening to what they have to say, because opinion makers are preoccupied with their own biases and opinions on how much the Nepali bureaucracy opposes elections.
Clearing the air
by: Mukesh Khanal
Critics of the newly formed interim council were quick to attack the council for being slow and not striving harder to hold elections in June. The current state of discussions suggests that it will most likely happen in November. In addition, some opinion makers were quick to blame state bureaucrats of being happy with current status quo, and accused them of trying to postpone elections for as long as they can. The implicit suggestion was that local bureaucrats tend to benefit significantly in absence of elected officials. The dread created amongst political activists in Tarai-Madhesh has been cited as an example of how this bureaucratic status quo results in despondency in the system. However, not many have actually bothered to ask the bureaucrats how they feel.
The fact that a status quo situation with no elections stands to benefit a handful of corrupt bureaucrats does not mean the entire bureaucracy is hell-bent on ensuring the postponement of elections. In the past few months, I have had opportunities to observe local and national level bureaucrats speak their opinions on popular public and political perception of Nepali bureaucracy. Contrary to popular belief, the bureaucrats stressed that they want elections just as badly as everyone else. They want local elections to be held before national elections. And many of us thought that they were happy with their current hold on power—handling local level duties of 22 different ministries and 58 different elected officials.
The perception of local bureaucracy being mired in corruption stems from a number of instances of corruption that have occurred and been reported. However, local bureaucrats suggest that transparency and accountability in municipal or VDC level governments is much higher when compared to other line agencies of Nepali government. Therefore, when local bureaucracy honestly reports and disseminates its transparency and accountability findings, Nepali media is quick to pounce on the few ‘negative’ instances in the overall transparent and accountable governance scenario. In other words, much of the perception about corruption in local bureaucracy is a creation of the media, according to local bureaucrats.
Although Nepali bureaucracy, especially VDCs and municipalities, get bad press for occasional instances of corruption, their role in keeping the country functioning during the absence of stable political government has to be lauded. Local elections have not happened in over 14 years, and elected representatives in local bodies have been absent for over 10 years now. In this entire duration, the fact that Nepali state has been functioning, and Nepal has not become a failed state, is a miracle with much credit going to our well oiled bureaucracy.
While accusing the local bureaucracy of mismanagement in decision-making, we have to take into account three kinds of pressures that local bureaucrats have to bear. First, decision-making in local level has to be done in a manner that appeases all sections of local society. Therefore, whether a VDC secretary or municipal executive officer likes it or not, he/she has to seek suggestions from local political actors while making decisions on complex problems. Any complex decision has to be taken with a political buy-in from all local political actors from all parties to ensure that they help in containing any possible public outburst against such decisions.
Second, although all party mechanism (APM) has been officially disbanded by the Nepali government, it still operates as the de-facto decision-making body in the local level. Earlier, when the APMs were created, they only had members from seven different political parties. Therefore, it was easier to come to a consensus in decision-making. However, the de-facto APMs of today consist of dozens of political parties—large and small—which has made decision-making very difficult in local government. Since each party wants a share of the pie, decision-making at local level has been obstructed incessantly in recent times, and productivity of local bureaucrats has fallen due to this obstruction.
Third, when the de-facto APM comes to a consensus and takes a decision, it is the local bureaucrat who has to take ‘ownership’ of that decision and abide by it, because the APM does not ‘technically’ exist in the eye of the law or national government. When questions are raised by activists and media about how budgets are allocated and how projects are undertaken, VDC secretaries and municipal executive officers are thrown under the bus by these de-facto APMs who do not come to the bureaucrats’ assistance in defending those allocations and undertakings.
It is very easy to accuse the entire bureaucracy of being corrupt and opposed to elections. However, the ground realities and interactions with local and national level bureaucrats provide a different understanding. Contrary to popular belief, local bureaucrats recognize that politics of opposition is necessary to make local decision-making process more transparent and accountable. They also realize that bureaucracy is an apolitical mechanism, and that is how it should be. Therefore, they demand local elections as much as the public. It’s just that nobody has been listening to what they have to say, because opinion makers are preoccupied with their own biases and opinions on how much the Nepali bureaucracy opposes elections.
Labels: bureaucracy, election, local government, nepal
Monday, January 21, 2013
Today’s Nepal and its missing morality
Political leaders who led and participated in the democratic movement
of 2046 BS are still referred to as “freedom fighters” in our daily parlance. There
was one who had been jailed by the Panchayat government. His best friend, a
fellow freedom fighter, would frequently visit his family during that period like
any good friend would. When the one in jail went home after being released, his
wife ran away with the best friend. The two best friends went on to become
ministers in the post-Panchayat pro-democratic government at the same time. In
any function one attended, the other would be absent in order to avoid any
confrontation. This continued until one died recently.
In another incident, another freedom fighter was caught jumping out of
a prostitute’s window not very long ago. There were a few who, when denied a
ministership by their respective political parties, ran as independents and
lost. These incidents and examples illustrate a lack of ethics, character and
morality in our political leadership. This lack of ethics, character and
morality then seeped into our bureaucracy and the larger civil society.
I know a few civil servants who are the best fathers, husbands, sons
and uncles for their children, wives, parents and nieces. One of them was an
officer who extracted money from Sita Rai in the now-infamous airport
immigration extortion and rape case. That civil servant is still in hiding. What
makes these best fathers, husbands, sons and uncles leave the confines of their
own homes and turn into the sleaziest of civil servants and the vilest of human
beings? I believe that this is replication, in civil service, of our Hindu
tradition of sweeping and mopping our own homes clean every morning while
throwing our filth and garbage right outside our boundary walls with complete
disregard of how our actions affect others in the society.
How else can we, otherwise, explain our public officials in immigration
and customs stealing two lakh rupees from a bruised and battered female worker
returning from Saudi Arabia? On top of the extortion, the female worker is,
then, handed over to a police officer who proceeds to rape her multiple times.
What kind of safety and security should our mothers, sisters, aunts, nieces and
grandmothers expect in this country where a police officer—entrusted with the
duty to protect and serve—systematically and methodically rapes them?
Our police and army perform excellently while earning dollar salaries
as UN peacekeeping forces in Africa. Why can’t these same police and army
personnel show same kind of dedication and duty while serving in Nepal? Why
can’t they fulfill their duties of “serve and protect” without unzipping their
pants to rape a Maina Sunuwar or a Sita Rai? In addition to committing gender
based violence crimes by themselves, our security forces are responsible in
aiding and abetting such crimes, too. Human rights organizations have reported
that—in most of Terai region—police officers have been mediating cases of
gender based violence instead of registering the cases and bringing the
perpetrators to justice. Police officers have been found conducting negotiations
between victim’s family, perpetrators and local political actors.
Amidst all these, our national government remains not only a meek
observer but actually contributes to the impunity. Murderers of journalist
Dekendra Thapa have taken responsibility for their crime and have asked to be
punished to the maximum extent allowable by the law. So, why is then the prime
minister of the country asking the investigation officers to drop the case
against the murderers who have confessed to their crimes and seek punishment?
The government has filed very few charges against the rapists, and has
doled out even fewer punishments. Instead, immediately after a rape case
becomes public news, the government announces monetary compensations to
victims. Why is the government paying compensation to rape victims? A monetary
compensation is not the first thing that victims of rape have in their minds
when they ask their government to hear their case. The perpetrator of rape
should be brought to justice and punished according to the law. In the event
that the law decides to award compensation, it should come from perpetrators,
not from the tax revenue that the government collects from hardworking everyday
Nepali like me.
Abraham Lincoln once said that if you want to test a man’s character,
you should give him power. Government bureaucrats who stole from, and then
handed Sita Rai over to the police officer, lost their character when in a
position of power. The police officer, who then raped Sita Rai, did the same.
The army officers who raped and killed Maina Sunuwar did the same. Our public
officials seem to be unable to keep their characters intact when in a position
of power. They seem to be the worst of human beings when in duty and in a
position of power.
Violence against Nepali women will continue because of impunity. None
or very little consequences for committing crimes fail to deter the criminals
from further committing similar crimes. If our government truly feels guilty
for the frequency in which Nepali women seem to be raped, announcing an
immediate monetary compensation is not the way to show that remorse. It should
draft better laws and stronger punishments to prevent such incidents from
occurring in the future. However, that has not been the case.
Further rapes and other forms of violence against Nepali women have
been reported even after public outrage against recent rape cases. A woman in
Banke and one in Bara were burnt alive by family members. A housemaid in
Kathmandu has been found dead under mysterious circumstances. A woman was raped
in one of the tea estates in Ilam. It seems the Nepali polity, bureaucracy and
society has collectively decided to go down the moral drain at the same time.
All because there is impunity to any and all crimes in today’s Nepal. Friedrich
Nietzsche, the philosopher, once said that fear is the mother of all morality.
Until and unless our polity, bureaucracy and society fear the consequence of
their heinous actions, they will stay amoral.
(c) Mukesh Khanal
Labels: bureaucracy, dekendra thapa, democracy, GBV, maina sunuwar, maoists, morality, nepal, nepal army, police, sita rai, violence
Subscribe to Posts [Atom]
